Monday, October 15, 2007

Homework in the Montessori Classroom: Does it Actually Help Students?


I did something this year that I've always wanted to do. I’m NOT assigning homework. For several years I've struggled with assigning homework. After all, the students who need the most practice are the ones who really need to be using the Montessori materials off the shelves, not working on abstract worksheets at home.

Over the years, I've tried several approaches to homework. I've had students work out of math textbooks at home and found that was inconsistent with what they were learning in class. I spent hours searching for the perfect worksheets to accompany math lessons that were given, making sure that they weren't too abstract if students were still using concrete materials.

What I found was that, in all of their good intentions to help, parents were becoming frustrated with their child’s homework and showing them “short-cuts”. This, of course, contradicted the Montessori approach of letting the child naturally come up with the shortcuts after having mastered the concept. Children were becoming frustrated and starting to doubt their own abilities.

Homework in the Montessori Classroom: Does it Actually Help Students?


I started wondering about why we assign homework in the first place. There has been an increase in the amount of homework assigned over the last twenty or more years. Children now as young as pre-school are coming home with worksheets to do at home each night. This has been done more and more as schools face ever increasing pressure to advance student achievement and test scores. However, research has shown that there is no connection between homework and academic success. As a matter of fact, author and educational researcher Alfie Kohn goes so far as to suggest abolishing homework altogether in his recent book, The Homework Myth.

I've also had parents tell me that homework is good for teaching their children about responsibility and time management. That it is useful for learning study skills and developing work ethics and that they expect me to assign homework based developing these principals in their children. Again, after careful researching, there is no direct correlation between these skills and assigning homework.

So, what are my students doing when they get home and have no homework? From the sounds of things, they’re working! That’s right. When it’s not assigned, homework isn't drudgery. Students are coming to school with stories that they've written at home and asking to read them to the class. They tell me that they’re doing math on their own. They’re researching far away places and about the seed pods and sea shells they've been finding on their weekend journeys. They’re reading voraciously.

In addition, there is no coercing and cajoling to get the work done. There are no tears and battles over not wanting to do homework. There are no late assignments. Now there’s time to play games and play outside. Relationships have improved at home and at school. Students are looking forward to coming to school in the morning and not dreading having to tell me that the homework wasn't completed. I think that this may have been one of the best educational experiments I've ever tried. And I’m sure my students would agree!

To read more about the Montessori method of teaching and philosophy, view Dr. Montessori's The Montessori Method online.
As much as possible, NAMC’s web blog reflects the Montessori curriculum as provided in its teacher training programs. We realize and respect that Montessori schools are unique and may vary their schedules and offerings in accordance with the needs of their individual communities. We hope that our readers will find our articles useful and inspiring as a contribution to the global Montessori community.
© North American Montessori Center - originally posted in its entirety at Montessori Teacher Training on Monday, October 15, 2007.

3 comments:

  1. I totally agree with you on homework - I just finished The Case Against Homework and it was very informative.

    My question is, does your "no-homework" policy cause any problems with other teachers at your school who do give homework?

    Or if a family who has one child in your class and one child in another class, does one child feel bad because they have assigned homework and the other doesn't?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Lori -

    I've worked in situations where the three Upper Elementary classrooms were so tied together in curriculum, if we fluctuated or deveated at all in homework practices, it was very upsetting to the parents and children. In this case, however, the 6 lower elementary classrooms all have their own homework policies. That has been the culture at the school for some time. I have not encountered any resistance either by teachers, parents, or children. Though at times, I do have parents asking if there is something they should be doing at home to help their children and I've had students ask when they'll get homework like their older siblings. Other than that, it seems to have worked out well this year.

    Michelle

    ReplyDelete
  3. If you started giving homework and would like to stop what would you do? I am a new lower elementary teacher and I was following suit of the other teachers instead of following the child. My first inclination of no home work except a reading log.

    ReplyDelete

Have questions or comments? Let us know what you thought about this article!

We appreciate feedback and love to discuss with our readers further.

NAMC Blog Inquiries Contact Form

Name

Email *

Message *

Search the NAMC Montessori Teacher Training Blog

Are you interested in reading back through NAMC's blog articles from years gone by, or for more information on a specific topic?

Browse a select list of our most popular categories below; by clicking on one, you will see every article posted under that topic since 2007. You may also use the lower archive menu to select a year and month, displaying all blog posts in the chosen time frame.

If you are seeking a range of information on a certain topic or idea, try this search box for site-wide keyword results.

Choose From a List of Popular Article Topics

NAMC Montessori Series

Montessori Philosophy and Methodology

Montessori Classroom Management

The School Year

Montessori Materials

Montessori Curriculum

Montessori Infant/Toddler (0–3) Program

Montessori Early Childhood (3–6) Program

Montessori Elementary (6–12) Programs

What is Montessori?

Search Archives for Montessori Blog Posts by Date


Thank you to the NAMC Montessori community!

NAMC has been providing quality Montessori distance training and curriculum development to Montessorians around the globe for more than 25 years. Since beginning in 1996, we have grown to build a fantastic community of students, graduates, and schools in over 160 countries. We are grateful for your continued support and dedication to furthering the reach and success of the Montessori method.